Thursday, 27 January 2011

Understanding job demands: hindrances and challenges are not the same

What's in a job? The Job Demands-Resources Model answers this question by defining two types of characteristics: job demands such as workload run down our energy and can harm our health, whereas job resources, including positive feedback, stimulate us and increase engagement. Neat, but the model has struggled with evidence that, against expectations, some job demands also link to higher levels of engagement.

A study by Anja Van den Broeck and colleagues approaches this by integrating work that carves demands into two further types. First are hindrances, e.g., repeated conflict: these provoke negative feeling, encouraging us to retreat into managing our feelings. Second are challenges, which include workload: these are still effortful but draw us toward a problem-solving stance which can lead to fulfillment and stimulation. Both types can run down our energy, but challenges can reward us in return.

Integrating this view into the model could remedy the inconsistencies - but not without answering some questions. Specifically, the hindrance-challenge research rarely considers job resources, and it's important to know what the beneficial effects of challenges are after resources are taken into account. (If increases in workload were sometimes accompanied by a free expresso, we'd want our analysis to separate caffeine from the workload effect.)

The study asked participants to complete questionnaires reporting levels of exhaustion (a measure of energy depletion) and vigour (stimulation), together with ratings of various job characteristics: demands (negative workhome interference and emotional demands), challenges (workload and cognitive demands), and resources (autonomy and social support). It used two samples, seeking to generalise beyond a single industry: these were 261 call centre agents and 441 police officers, distinctive due to more education and seniority.

They found that higher vigour - the good stuff - was not only associated with lower hindrances and higher job resources, but also with higher job challenges. Modelling the data confirmed that challenges had a significant and separate effect to job resources. (Bang goes my expresso theory.)

The story for exhaustion was less straightforward. Generally it increased with higher job demands and lower job resources*, in line with expectations. However the authors found no relationship either way to job challenges surprising, as traditionally these would be classed as job demands, and demands = energy depletion. The authors recommend future work consider treating energy as elastic rather than as a fixed resource: challenges may produce energy to balance what they expend.

The study makes it clear that job challenges are made of different stuff from both job resources and their job demand cousins, hindrances, and modelling the data using three characteristics did a better job than the Demand-Resource model (or indeed, other ways to pair the characteristics).


As a practitioner, a model is a useful way to carve up the world: to consider the stresses and supports in a role for job redesign, or as touch-points for a developmental discussion. Many such models are spirited out of the air, and an approach that's evidence based is hugely preferable.

But when a model doesn't reflect the nuance of personal experience, people won't buy it. For many people, the cognitive load of a job isn't simply a hassle, a drain. It has a further quality, one the study's authors relate to Selye's concept of eustress- stress that spurs us forward. To separate these challenges from the disruptive distress of a hindrance feels right, and this study provides evidence that doing so sharpens this solid model of what's in a job.

Van den Broeck, A., De Cuyper, N., De Witte, H. & Vansteenkiste, M. (2010). Not all job demands are equal: Differentiating job hindrances and job challenges in the Job Demands–Resources model. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 19(6), 735-759. doi:10.1080/13594320903223839

*For the call centre workers, job resources did not relate to exhaustion. The authors suggest that in this group of more temporary workers exhaustion was driven by immediate concerns rather than long-term issues the resources can shield against.


  1. The European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology article referred to in this post is now free to read in full online for the next few weeks.

    Click here to go straight through to the full text.

  2. Now that is the thing that I call an epic blog. Superbly made.

  3. Thank You for sharing this wonderful blog. Also you check the best bank job circular

  4. Thanks for Sharing a Good Article. you may Check ssc result 2019 Comilla board

  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

  6. Thank you so much for giving pieces of information. Government Job BD

  7. Every year ssc result will published within 3 month after finished exam.
    All Education board announced their
    ssc exam result 2020 via official notice. Most probably, SSC result 2020 published on 6 may 2020. Most of the
    time result will published on after 2 pm.

  8. I Ariful Islam is your Lyrics, entertainment, music fashion website. We provide you with the latest Lyrics from the entertainment industry

  9. Thanks for sharing this wonderful article with us..
    SSC Result 2020 will be available at this website at SSC Result 2020 and it will be published in May 2020.
    You also see full Marksheet here at SSC Result 2020
    You can get all Public Examinations Educational Result BD
    You may also check PSC Result 2020

  10. Hello , I perpetually follow your website and take a look at to find out one thing additional what i do know. I actually have browse this web blog and extremely pleased with you that you simply square measure extremely doing well. Thanks for staying with worldwide, Hopefully it'll be continuing.



  11. I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people. Thanks for sharing the information keep updating,
    looking forward to more posts. Thank you

  12. Anonymous said...
    I regularly visit your site and find a lot of interesting information. Thank you and look forward to your page growing stronger.

  13. This excellent looks absolutely appropriate. Every one of moderate information are ready by using large number associated
    with encounter useful understanding. I am eager this once again greatly.
    SSC Result 2020

  14. AKSID Corporation Ltd Job Circular 2020 প্রকাশিত হয়েছে। অসহায় মানুষের পক্ষে এটি একটি দুর্দান্ত ক্যারিয়ারের সুযোগ এবং বেকার লোকদের খুব বেশি প্রয়োজন এই চাকুরীটি। AKSID Corporation Ltd এখনই বিশ্বের সর্বাধিক জনপ্রিয় সংস্থা কোম্পানী AKSID। এই সংস্থা আমাদের অনেক পণ্য এবং সর্বোত্তম পরিষেবা সরবরাহ করছে। সম্পর্কিত তথ্য পেতে, আপনি দেখতে পারেন AKSID Corporation Ltd Job Circular 2020

  15. Nice Post