Tuesday, 24 July 2012

Emotional Intelligence helps manage team issues - but not in every context

Past research has confirmed that emotional intelligence (EI) is more important in jobs such as teaching or nursing because it provides resources and methods for personally managing the high emotional loads common to such positions. A new paper demonstrates that jobs that involve high managerial demands benefit from EI for a different reason: the specific ability to detect emotional cues helps smooth over issues and keep team relations positive. However, in some cases, EI could be doing harm rather than good.

EI can be conceptualised in many ways, and lead researcher Crystal Farh and her colleagues chose to focus on Mayer and Salovey’s model, a purely ability-focused scheme that comprises emotional perception, the use of emotions to facilitate thinking, understanding emotions, and regulating emotions. They asked 212 early-career managers to complete web surveys that measured personality together with managerial work demands, defined by items such as "This job is a dramatic increase in scope". Managerial demands were of interest because they reflect work situations that are challenging and involve degrees of stress and intense emotions to deliver ambitious outcomes; Farh's team believed that emotional cues in these contexts need to be picked up quickly by managers. EI was measured through a series of standardised ability tests, and participants' supervisors contributed ratings of overall job performance together with perceptions of how effective the participant's team was.

 When managerial work demands were great, higher EI was associated with higher teamwork effectiveness, but the relationship disappeared when the managerial demands were at or beyond one standard deviation below the sample average. EI made a difference in busy, complex and multi-layered managerial contexts, not when managing single teams under less pressured conditions. Farh's team predicted that the first EI component, emotional perception, would be the most crucial component, because noticing emotions is a precondition to acting upon them. They duly found that when each component was analysed separately, only emotional perception maintained the effect under high managerial demands; moreover, when those demands were low, emotional perception was actually associated with a penalty to teamworking. Why? The paper conjectures that being hypersensitive to emotional cues in a low-stress environment may actually be counterproductive, leading to 'reading too much' into situations and rocking the boat unnecessarily.

Does teamworking matter? An analysis demonstrated that in this sample, higher EI was associated with better job performance, and this was due to the positive relationship between EI and teamwork effectiveness. All analyses controlled for personality, as in particular conscientiousness tends to be tied to meeting specified work outcomes.

The research adds to the literature that EI matters in a range of work roles, acting as a solution to specific problems rather than acting as a global resource that improves every situation.  The authors conclude that 'managers should recognize that selecting emotionally intelligent employees or training employees’ EI may not lead to higher performance outcomes in all situations, but that investing in the EI of employees working in jobs characterized by high managerial demands may be a worthwhile endeavour.'

ResearchBlogging.orgCrystal I Chien Farh, Myeong-Gu Seo, & Paul E. Tesluk (2012). Emotional intelligence, teamwork effectiveness, and job performance: The moderating role of job context. Journal of Applied Psychology, 97 (4), 890-900 DOI: 10.1037/a0027377


  1. Stephen Mugford26 July 2012 at 03:10

    CF the interesting paper Myriam N. Bechtoldt, Bianca Beersma, Sonja Rohrmann &
    Jeffrey Sanchez-Burks (2011): A gift that takes its toll: Emotion recognition and
    conflict appraisal, European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,
    This argues that a strong capacity to read emotion can lead to interpreting conflict as personal rather than task oriented. stakes then rise and resolution is ahrder. Fits with this one ...

  2. Anyone who concludes that "EI could be doing harm rather than good" - in any situation, demonstrates an appalling lack of understanding of the concept of EI. Also, what is meant by "...'reading too much' into situations and rocking the boat unnecessarily" - this is just reckless. How can one possibly "read too much into a situation"? And what the hell does "rocking the boat unnecessarily" mean? This was peer reviewed? Who were the peers?

    1. Thanks Stephen, very relevant reference.

      Anonymous, I think Stephen's reference is pertinent to your concerns. If EI is conceptualised to include a sensitivity to emotional cues, if there are clearly situations where that could be unhelpful. An analogous situation that springs to mind is
      catastrophic overinterpretation of bodily cues, where an overly sensitive attention to feelings emanating from the body can lead to negative outcomes - see eg
      on panic disorder, or
      on panic disorder and depression; the work I used to be familiar with focused on travel sickness and nausea.

      Similarly, high levels of neuroticism tend to be associated with hypersensitivity to social cues that lead to concerns about how people think of you, which risks creating negative feedback loops of distancing relationships.

      The general principle is that once a notion takes up real estate in our mind it frames our experiences, carrying the risk of creating or inflating an issue that might otherwise have naturally dissipated.

      Moving beyond the individual to the group level, EI can lead to negative outcomes such as higher rates of deviant behaviour. http://bps-occupational-digest.blogspot.com/2011/04/organisations-are-your-citizens.html


  3. Wow! It's a great knowledge to post in your blog. intelligence is a best way to promote your business.

  4. beautiful doodlekit templates 2008 http://bestonlinecasinoworld.tumblr.com casino games online

  5. I am exceptionally glad to read your post. Nice topic. I could have collected so many information from your post. I hope all that will help me in my future. Same, there is one consulting services in Australia named like Glass Rock Consulting giving
    Emotional Intelligence Training
    specifically designed as a core foundational capability for management and teams.

  6. Hey,
    I really appreciate the information shared by you and conducting an emotional intelligence course workshop at the workplace can prove to be an asset and help the employees. The information that you've shared is very helpful.